The feature sends previous messages to Google servers, even with end-to-end encryption (E2EE).
Google has taken a significant step in the realm of AI-assisted messaging with the launch of Magic Compose, a beta feature for its Messages app. Magic Compose utilizes artificial intelligence to provide users with text message suggestions, enhancing their messaging experience. However, there is an important caveat to consider, as pointed out by Android Police: the feature sends up to “20 previous messages” to Google’s servers, even when end-to-end encryption (E2EE) is enabled via Rich Communication Services (RCS).
A Deeper Look at Magic Compose’s Functionality
On the Magic Compose support page, Google explicitly explains the conditions of using the feature. To enable its AI to generate appropriate responses, the feature transmits the selected messages, including any accompanying emoji, reactions, and URLs, to Google’s servers. It’s important to note that Magic Compose does not send messages containing attachments, voice messages, or images. However, Google acknowledges that “image captions and voice transcriptions may be sent” to assist with generating suggestions.
After introducing end-to-end encryption (E2EE) to its messaging app in 2020, Google expanded its support to include group chats. E2EE provides users with the assurance that their messages cannot be accessed by Google or any other third party. However, when Magic Compose is used in conjunction with E2EE, messages are transmitted to Google’s servers. Nevertheless, Google asserts that it still cannot decipher the actual content of these messages.
In a statement to The Verge, Google spokesperson Justin Rende clarified that the conversation data utilized by Magic Compose is not stored or retained by the company. Furthermore, the suggested response outputs generated by the AI are also not kept once they have been presented to the user. Google reassures users that when Magic Compose is inactive, their messages are not transmitted to Google’s servers.
Magic Compose: A Highlight from Google’s I/O Event
Magic Compose is just one of the innovative AI-powered features unveiled by Google at its recent I/O event. The feature enables users to reply to text messages by selecting stylized, contextually appropriate suggestions. Currently, Magic Compose is being gradually rolled out to users who are part of the Google Messages beta program.
When users have access to the feature, they will immediately spot a chat bubble icon located next to the message composer within the app. By selecting a suggested response, users have the option to further customize the text using a range of preset styles, including options like “chill,” “excited,” or even adopting a “Shakespearean” tone. It is important to note that Magic Compose currently supports RCS messages, but there is no confirmation yet regarding its support for SMS/MMS.
Similar AI-Enhanced Features Introduced by Microsoft
Microsoft has also ventured into the realm of AI-assisted messaging with the introduction of a comparable feature in its keyboard app, SwiftKey. This feature enables users to compose text messages and emails by selecting the Bing icon within the app’s toolbar. Furthermore, users can customize the tone, format, and length of the suggested messages, providing them with a tailored messaging experience.
As Google continues to refine Magic Compose and gather user feedback during the beta phase, the company aims to enhance the efficiency and convenience of text messaging by leveraging AI and contextual suggestions.
